Homemade Vanilla

I know I am not the first person to talk about homemade vanilla. Probably not even the 1,001! But I have made it, and I am making even more (double) as I write this. In fact, this is last years batch pictured in this post. I waited the entire year to make sure this is something I would recommend to you. This super easy project has my ringing endorsement for ease, cost, and flavor.

Let's get to it!

Supplies

  • Big ol' bottle of alcohol. I am using bourbon, because I like the flavor. Vodka or rum are also good choices. 1.75 liters

  • Vanilla beans. I chose Madagascar beans. I suggest starting with about 50 vanilla pods.

  • Knife and cutting board.

  • Something to pour a little bit of your liquor into to make room for the vanilla beans.

Instructions

  • Split your vanilla bean pods in half lengthwise. I didn't bother to fully split them. I left them attached by just a little at one end.

  • Start adding your split vanilla pods to your bottle of liquor.

  • Pour off liquor as needed to make room for the vanilla pods.

  • Tighten the cap back on.

  • Give it a shake.

  • Store somewhere you can get to it.

  • Shake it once per month.

  • Store for at least 4 months, but I recommend an entire year.

Now you have vanilla that is suitable for baking and flavoring anything you like. It may seem like a lot of money at first, but look at the price per ounce of the 'gourmet' vanilla in the stores! With a little patience, and hardly any work, you will have your own vanilla, that is just as good, if not better, for a fraction of the store price!

I gave some of my batch away as Christmas gifts last year. Not all of it, of course. I really liked how it turned out! I found the cute little bottles on Amazon.

If you're wondering what to do with all those used vanilla beans, I have some ideas!

  • Just leave them in your bottle. They'll add a little more flavor the longer you leave them.

  • Add some to granulated or brown sugar to make vanilla sugar.

  • Scrape the seeds out of the pods and use them in recipes calling for vanilla beans. Like ice cream!

  • Use them whole for recipes that call for the whole pod. I like to simmer them in things like the base for custard or vanilla pudding.

  • Compost them. A bit of a waste I think, but better than just throwing them in the trash.

There you have it, folks! I hope you'll give making your own vanilla a try. Little things we do for ourselves can make our lives so much better, and tastier! Thanks for being here!

Copyright© 2026 What Don't I Do. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer: As a systeme.io affiliate, I earn a commission if you purchase a product through my link, at no additional cost to you.